May 17, 2022 #1 Local News, Forum, Information and Event Source for Venice Beach, California.

Column: Response to Nick Antonicello’s Recent Yo! Venice Pieces About the City’s Failure to Take Any Steps to Effectively Deal With Homelessness

By Clark Brown, Member Venice Neighborhood Council

Nick Antonicello’s recent columns in Yo! Venice regarding the City’s failure to take effective steps to deal with the homeless encampments in Venice have great merit. These columns are: His April 30 column(“An Open Letter to LA County Sheriff Alex Villanueva—Help Us Clean Up Centennial Park Now!”), his April 21 column (“No Need for a ‘Tsar,’ the Need Is Results in Getting the Homeless off the Streets of LA & Venice Now!”) and his April 20 column (“Council Candidate Mike Newhouse Unveils Comprehensive Plan to Eliminate Street Homelessness by Clearing Encampments in 30-Days of Assuming Office!”)

Nick Antonicello is correct in his April 30 column that the Sheriff is far more likely than the City, the LAPD or anyone else to move the encampments from Centennial Park as well as the other areas where they now exist. (The areas around the Bridge Home, Electric and Venice, Flower Street, and Rose Avenue) 

These encampments flagrantly violate established City ordinances. These include: LAMC secs. 41.18(a)(b) “Obstructing Sidewalks, Streets, Public Rights of Way,” 41.18(c)(d) “Camping within 500’ of Sensitive Facilities and 1000’ of Homeless Service Facilities,” 80.89.4 regulating “Oversized Vehicles” and its September 3, 2021 ordinance which bars camping in Parks.

Yet, no-one in the City is willing to enforce these ordinances. Mayor Garcetti is only focused on becoming Ambassador to India. Councilman Bonin actually supports the homeless encampments because he believes they create political pressure for permanent housing, which he contends is the only solution to the encampments even though such housing is prohibitively expensive. So Bonin has barred the LAPD from enforcing the ordinances above described. LAPD Chief Moore does what Bonin tells him to do.

That leaves Sheriff Villanueva as the only official willing or able to do anything about the encampments. But due to the decision in Martin v. Boise 920 F3d 584 he can’t enforce the City’s ordinances unless the City has places to which it can move the encampments. All that’s required is to provide the encampment inhabitants a place to which they can move their tents. But no one admits this is the factor which impedes resolution of the encampment issue. 

Fortunately, there is a solution.  The City can move the encampments to a large, abandoned, city owned, subdivision of many acres  at the intersection of Century and La Cienega north of LAX. It is crisscrossed with roads and has existing infrastructure for water, gas, sewer and electricity. This subdivision was formerly known as Manchester Square. It’s not near houses, schools or churches so it won’t interfere with family activities. See attached photos.  San Francisco, Sacramento, Houston  and Oceanside  have successfully used city owned lots for this purpose.  Later tiny homes could be built on this parcel as CD2 has done. 

The Venice Neighborhood Council and its Homelessness Committee share responsibility for the City’s abject failure to use Manchester Square as a place to move the encampments. For its officers have vigorously opposed using Manchester Square for this purpose. This has happened because the VNC’s President, Jim Murez, is running for the City Council in CD 11 which includes Venice and Westchester. He wants the support of Westchester where Manchester Square is located because he has concluded Westchester opposes using any part of its community for the homeless. That’s more important to him than what’s in Venice’s best interest.

Murez abjectly bowed to his gross conflict of interest. Moving the Venice encampments to Manchester Square is in Venice’s best in because it’s the only near term solution to the homeless encampments. Murez favors Westchester over Venice because he wants its support for his candidacy for the City Council to replace Bonin. 

Murez was supported by other prominent members of the VNC Board who were on his “Common Sense Venice” slate during the VNC elections last summer.. Nico Ruderman, another VNC Board member, also opposed moving the encampments to Manchester Square. He too had a gross conflict of interest because he was running for the Assembly in both Westchester and Venice. (He recently withdrew.) 

Frank Murphy, who Murez appointed as chair of the VNC Homelessness Committee, also supported Murez’s campaign to deep six the only proposal the VNC has considered to move the encampments from Venice. Under his leadership the VNC has refused to consider any other proposals to do that. 

Even worse, Murez, his “Common Sense Venice” allies on the VNC Board, Murphy and his Homelessness Committee have proposed no solutions to move the encampments from Venice and have actively opposed all proposals to do that. 

In short, the VNC is all about politics and not doing anything to move the homeless from Venice to other locations where their needs can better be met.

The City has claimed that Federal law, FAA regulations and policies bar the City from using Manchester Square for encampments and tiny homes. But the City has provided no documents or any other evidence to support its claim despite a public records request and numerous other requests since last October. In fact, in its response to the public records request the City admitted in writing it has no such documents.

Enough is enough. Everyone should get Murez, the VNC, its Homelessness Committee, Murphy and the City to support the Manchester Square solution so Sheriff Villanueva can enforce the City’s ordinances and move the encampments from Venice. This would be best for Venice and its unhoused.

in Opinion
Related Posts

Column: CD-11 Candidates Darling & Good Equal an Even More Dangerous Path on Homelessness Than Mike Bonin!

May 12, 2022

May 12, 2022

By Nick Antonicello Just when you thought things could get better, two Mike Bonin “clones” in CD-11 council hopefuls Erin...

Column: Ruderman Endorses Pullen-Miles For Assembly, Hosts Event In Venice Wednesday Evening At Waterfront Café!

May 10, 2022

May 10, 2022

Venice Community Officer & Bonin Recall Proponent calls Pullen-Miles the right choice for Venetians! By Nick Antonicello Lawndale Mayor Robert...

Column: Homelessness – One With a Specific Plan and Timeline, and Those Without!

May 9, 2022

May 9, 2022

Candidate Newhouse stands out as the “man with a plan” on ending the encampment crisis here in Venice and beyond!...

Column: Cities Fight to Maintain Distinctive Characters

May 6, 2022

May 6, 2022

By Tom Elias, Columnist Anyone who knows California well will realize that Palo Alto does not look much like nearby...

Column: Jim Murez’s Response to Recent Letter to the Editor

May 5, 2022

May 5, 2022

Editor’s note: the following is a column from CD 11 candidate Jim Murez in response to a recent Letter to...

Column: This Election Isn’t Over, It’s Wide Open. Here’s Why

May 5, 2022

May 5, 2022

By Craig Greiwe, LA Mayoral Candidate The press would have you believe the Los Angeles Mayor’s Race is a contest...

Column: “You Got Mail”

May 4, 2022

May 4, 2022

Prepare for the deluge of direct mail as the various campaigns for council, supervisor, and other state offices comes to...

Column: Newhouse for LA City Council Raises Over $265,000 in Just 70 Days!

May 4, 2022

May 4, 2022

Venice Community Advocate Outperforms CD-11 Field, Double-downs on pledge to remove homeless encampments in 30 days upon assuming office! By...

Column: An Open Letter To LA County Sheriff Alex Villanueva – Help Us Cleanup Centennial Park Now!

April 29, 2022

April 29, 2022

Dear Sheriff Villanueva: The residents of Venice need your help once again. This time, we need your help to take...

Column: No Need for a ‘Tsar,’ the Need Is Results in Getting the Homeless off the Streets of LA & Venice Now!

April 21, 2022

April 21, 2022

By Nick Antonicello Venice resident Michael Rapkin’s awkward and highly controversial premise that a single position or individual can somehow...

Column: Rick Caruso On Taxes, Just Like Trump?

April 21, 2022

April 21, 2022

By Nick Antonicello In a press conference held Monday in Marina Del Rey, L.A. City Attorney & Mayoral Candidate Mike...

Column: “We Need A Working-Class Minority Voice That Is Centered For The Rest Are Just More Of The Same.”

April 18, 2022

April 18, 2022

Venice HS Teacher, Union Rep and All-American Track Star makes the case for real change in CD-11 race to succeed...

Independent Expenditures Committee Raises $550,000 in Support of Council Candidates Soto, Price and Good, KDL for Mayor, Opposing O’Farrell for Council!

April 14, 2022

April 14, 2022

Column by Nick Antonicello According to the Los Angeles Ethics Commission, a political independent expenditures committee has raised $550,000 to...

Column: Feuer Calls Caruso’s $10 Million in Loans to Campaign ‘A Charade That Evades the Spirit of L.a.’s Finance Laws’

April 11, 2022

April 11, 2022

Feuer says Caruso’s strategy will require a special interest fundraising binge! By Nick Antonicello L.A. City Attorney Mike Feuer last...