August 25, 2019 #1 Local News, Forum, Information and Event Source for Venice Beach, California.

OPINION: Homeless By Choice?

by Mike Bonin

In nearly every corner of Los Angeles, there are homeless encampments — collections of flimsy tents, usually within mere feet of a school, a park, a business, or someone’s home. Their presence invariably sparks a neighborhood debate, with loud voices proclaiming that “those people” are there by choice.

It’s not politically correct to admit it, but it’s true: most people in Los Angeles are homeless by choice. Our choice, not theirs.

Many major cities have a large homeless population, but only in Los Angeles does such a large percentage sleep without any sort of roof, seeking refuge on cold, hard pavement. That may not be by design, but it’s also not accidental, or unforeseeable.

In 2006, a federal court told the City of Los Angeles it was “cruel and unusual punishment” to forbid people from sleeping on sidewalks unless the City offered sufficient housing and shelter as an alternative. For a decade, rather than provide housing or shelter, the City effectively said, “let them eat asphalt,” and encampments proliferated nearly everywhere. By refusing to choose shelter, we chose sidewalks.

In the past two years, elected officials and the electorate said “enough.” We developed a comprehensive homelessness strategy, approved new dedicated funding, and started housing people at an impressive, record clip. Yet homelessness increased and encampments proliferated.

Part of the reason is that public officials, foundations, and service providers are making the perfect the enemy of the good. We are so determined to build permanent supportive housing — which is expensive and can take years to bring online — that we fail to address the here and now. We desperately need thousands of units of permanent supportive housing (and I have proposed hundreds of units in my district), but that doesn’t help the people sleeping in a tent tonight.

Call it crisis housing, bridge housing, or interim housing. Call it shelter, if you want. We need places where people can sleep next week, next month, and even next year until enough housing is available. Not bare-bones, one-size-fits-all shelters that feel like prisons, and become permanent warehouses for people. We need specialized, welcoming centers or shared housing for couples, for families with children, for teenage runaways, for veterans, and others. Low-barrier, round-the-clock accommodations that are genuinely a first-step to permanent housing.

Our bureaucracies and our institutions have a hard time with that. They know how to approve development. They are accustomed to the slow, complex financing systems, and the arcane rules. They are not used to urgency. They operate at a traditional speed when we sorely need an emergency response. It has been two years since the City Council adopted a comprehensive homelessness strategy calling for an increase in and transformation of shelter — and the Los Angeles Homeless Services Authority still has no strategy to get thousands of people off the street anytime soon. Bureaucratic inertia is at least as a big a hurdle as neighborhood opposition to specific projects.

During recent fires, officials announced the location of emergency shelters within hours of deploying first responders to burning homes. Victims of natural disasters are not left to sleep on our streets, but refugees from economic hardship, gentrification, a housing shortage, domestic violence, sexual abuse, addiction and mental illness are left to fend for themselves in the elements. That is unacceptable and intolerable.

We must insist on a range of immediate options for housing and shelter — even if it means using every available city facility, and every church or temple in Los Angeles. If we don’t, encampments will proliferate, and men, women and children will continue to live on our streets by choice — our choice.
________________________________

Councilmember Mike Bonin

Mike Bonin represents the Westside on the Los Angeles City Council and sits on the Council’s Homelessness and Poverty Committee. He and his colleague Marqueece Harris-Dawson have submitted legislation calling on LAHSA to develop an immediate plan to shelter people living in sidewalk encampments.

Related Posts

Edify TV: Coral Trees and Gophers

August 21, 2019

August 21, 2019

Brentwood’s coral trees are in trouble and gophers may be to blame. Learn more about the uncertain future of these...

GoTopless Day Returns to Venice this Weekend

August 20, 2019

August 20, 2019 1

Movement that raises awareness about gender inequality comes to Venice Beach Sunday By Keldine Hull GoTopless Day, a movement that...

Largest Recycling Buyback Center in California Shuts Down

August 20, 2019

August 20, 2019

rePlanet shuts down all California locations  By Keldine Hull  On August 5, California’s largest recycling collection network, rePlanet, has closed...

Man Shot by Police in Venice, Developer Fined for Bulldozing Playa del Rey Dunes: Yo! Venice This Week August 19

August 19, 2019

August 19, 2019

Yo! Venice This Week August 19 • Man shot by police in Venice• Developer fined for bulldozing Playa del Rey sand...

Man Who Approached Armored Truck in Santa Monica Shot

August 16, 2019

August 16, 2019

Man who approached armored truck shot, in custody By Sam Catanzaro A security guard opened fire at a knife-wielding suspect...

Guy Camilleri: A Surfer in New York!

August 16, 2019

August 16, 2019

By Guy Camilleri As an actor, I can’t help but feel strongly about what actors go through to be seen...

Man Shot by Police in Venice Wednesday

August 15, 2019

August 15, 2019

Man suffers non-life-threatening injuries after police open fire By Sam Catanzaro A man was shot by Los Angeles Police Department...

E-Scooters Not as Green as They Seem?

August 14, 2019

August 14, 2019

Recent study complicates understanding of e-scooters’ environmental impact. By Kai McNamee After taking Santa Monica and Los Angeles by storm,...

Coastal Commission Issues Cease and Desist to Developer who Bulldozed Playa Dunes

August 13, 2019

August 13, 2019

Ecologically–sensitive dunes graded by Legado Companies By Sam Catanzaro The California Coastal Commission (CCC) is taking swift and forceful action after...

Bonin Demands Legal Action After Developer Bulldozes Playa Sand Dunes

August 13, 2019

August 13, 2019

Ecologically–sensitive dunes graded by Legado Companies By Sam Catanzaro After a developer bulldozed ecologically sensitive sand dunes in Playa Del...

LA County Adopts One of Nation’s Most Ambitious Sustainability Plans

August 12, 2019

August 12, 2019 1

By Sam Catanzaro The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors last week unanimously adopted the OurCounty Sustainability Plan, one of...

E-scooters Not as Green as They Seem? Planter Boxes Spark Venice Debate: Yo! Venice This Week August 12

August 12, 2019

August 12, 2019

Yo! Venice This Week August 12 • E-scooters not as green as they seem • Planter boxes spark Venice debateShow made possible...

The Link Between Hearing Loss and Dementia

August 11, 2019

August 11, 2019

Dr. Melissa Alexander helping patients minimize effects of hearing loss   By Keldine Hull  The ability to hear can have a...

Bird Rolls Out New Device

August 9, 2019

August 9, 2019

Company touting durability of Bird Two By Sam Catanzaro There is a shiny new bird in town.  Bird this week rolled...

Yo! Venice TGIF Show August 9

August 9, 2019

August 9, 2019

Yo! Venice TGIF Show August 9 – all your fun local events and happenings in under 5 minutes. • Culver Hotel...