May 20, 2022 #1 Local News, Forum, Information and Event Source for Venice Beach, California.

Venice Stakeholders Files Appeal in Public Nuisance Lawsuit for Conditions Along Venice Beach

OPINION

8:02pm

By Mark Ryavec

Last week our organization filed an appeal in our lawsuit against the City and County of Los Angeles for their maintenance of a public nuisance and dangerous conditions along the Venice Boardwalk and beach. In the suit the Stakeholders contend that these conditions deprive residents of the quiet and safe enjoyment of their homes and the Venice community of the safe use of the Venice Beach Recreation Area.

Judge Gregory Alarcon had sided late last year with the VSA against the City’s and County’s motions for summary judgment. However, when the City and County appealed his decision our organization did not file a legal brief at the appellate level due to the advice of several attorneys that such requests for a “writ of mandate” are rarely granted. Unfortunately for Venice residents, this was one of the rare cases in which that maxim did not hold up.

At that point in January we reached out to the City and asked Councilman Bonin if he would meet with us on behalf of the City to address our concerns about noise, crime, burglaries, trespass and the inability of the public and residents to enjoy many areas along the Boardwalk that have been taken over perma- nently by transients and vendors.

Mr. Bonin did not reply to our invitation.

This is the opposite tack from that taken by his predecessor, the late Councilman Bill Rosendahl. When we first considered filing a

public nuisance lawsuit several years ago, Bill immediately asked then-City Attorney Car- men Trutanich to meet with us to see if the City could address our concerns. We had sev- eral discussions with the City Attorney’s staff and the result was that the City Attorney led several City departments, along with the council office (where Bonin was the chief deputy), in an effort to improve public safety along the Boardwalk. This included the installation of new signage that banned camping along the Boardwalk and beach and high- lighted the 12 to 5am beach curfew. This was followed by renewed enforcement of the camping ban and beach curfew by the LAPD as long as Rosendahl was in office.

When it became evident in 2014 under the new regime of Bonin, Mayor Eric Garcetti, City Attorney Mike Feuer and Supervisor Sheila Kuehl that the City and County were not enforcing “no camping” and “no storage” laws and noise limits in the Venice Beach Recreation Area, we met with City Attorney Feuer. In the course of the meeting we told him that we were contemplating a public nui- sance lawsuit. Unlike Mr. Trutanich and Bill Rosendahl, who headed off our lawsuit by ramping up City enforcement, Feuer said, “Well, it’s your right to sue.” So, we did.

Today the contrast between the City’s and County’s lack of enforcement along the Boardwalk compared to other parks continues to be striking. As we pointed out three years ago, many areas of Venice Beach are covered by tons of private possessions of both vendors and transients, while the park next to City Hall DTLA is kept in pristine condition. The same laws that govern the City Hall park govern Venice Beach, and were employed to remove Occupy LA from the front of City Hall a few years ago. But under the current authorities, little is enforced here in Venice. In fact, residents who live along the Board- walk and walk streets have told me that the situation has deteriorated in recent months.

The City has recently amended two ordinances, LAMC 63.44, which now significantly limits what can be taken into a park in the day and requires that every item leave a park at night, and LAMC 56.11, which reduces what can be stored on a sidewalk, gives the City lat- itude to remove bulky items, and shortens the notice period. However, there has been no move to enforce these new laws in Venice, a failure I attribute to Mr. Bonin. If there had been, this might address some of the issues raised in our suit, and lead to fruitful negotia- tions with the City. But again, Bonin has not returned our call.

The law under which we brought the case is the same law the City Attorney uses to close down crack dens and other buildings that gen- erate crime and activities which are a nuisance to neighbors. Certainly the Boardwalk, as an elongated drug emporium and crime genera- tor, is a public nuisance the City Attorney would move to close if it was in private hands. The City’s and County’s failure to enforce their own laws against drug sales, camping, tents, noise, public inebriation, defecation and urination, and storage of private property on park land all contribute to the erosion of residents safety and quiet enjoyment of their homes.

In their appeal of Judge Alarcon’s initial decision to dismiss their motions for summary judgment, the City and County did not dis- pute that their lack of enforcement caused the public nuisances that residents constantly experience. Instead, they pointed to munici- palities’ “prosecutorial discretion;” i.e., their right to decide what laws to enforce and when to enforce them. Without a legal brief from us rebutting this claim, the Appellate Court gave Judge Alarcon a choice of letting us belatedly submit a legal brief opposing the City and County’s position or dismissing the case. He chose the latter, which set up our right to appeal the entire case to the Appeals Court, known as a “de novo” review. Instead of just appealing the narrow issue of prosecutorial discretion we will be trying the entire case before the Appeals Court.

The case will probably be heard late this summer. Donations to the legal fund are welcome and can be sent to the VSA at 1615 Andalusia Avenue, Venice, CA 90291.

Mark Ryavec is president of the non-profit Venice Stakeholders Association.

Columnist Mark Ryavec.
Columnist Mark Ryavec.
Tags: in Opinion
Related Posts

Column: CD-11 Candidates Darling & Good Equal an Even More Dangerous Path on Homelessness Than Mike Bonin!

May 12, 2022

May 12, 2022

By Nick Antonicello Just when you thought things could get better, two Mike Bonin “clones” in CD-11 council hopefuls Erin...

Column: Ruderman Endorses Pullen-Miles For Assembly, Hosts Event In Venice Wednesday Evening At Waterfront Café!

May 10, 2022

May 10, 2022

Venice Community Officer & Bonin Recall Proponent calls Pullen-Miles the right choice for Venetians! By Nick Antonicello Lawndale Mayor Robert...

Column: Homelessness – One With a Specific Plan and Timeline, and Those Without!

May 9, 2022

May 9, 2022

Candidate Newhouse stands out as the “man with a plan” on ending the encampment crisis here in Venice and beyond!...

Column: Cities Fight to Maintain Distinctive Characters

May 6, 2022

May 6, 2022

By Tom Elias, Columnist Anyone who knows California well will realize that Palo Alto does not look much like nearby...

Column: Jim Murez’s Response to Recent Letter to the Editor

May 5, 2022

May 5, 2022

Editor’s note: the following is a column from CD 11 candidate Jim Murez in response to a recent Letter to...

Column: This Election Isn’t Over, It’s Wide Open. Here’s Why

May 5, 2022

May 5, 2022

By Craig Greiwe, LA Mayoral Candidate The press would have you believe the Los Angeles Mayor’s Race is a contest...

Column: “You Got Mail”

May 4, 2022

May 4, 2022

Prepare for the deluge of direct mail as the various campaigns for council, supervisor, and other state offices comes to...

Column: Newhouse for LA City Council Raises Over $265,000 in Just 70 Days!

May 4, 2022

May 4, 2022

Venice Community Advocate Outperforms CD-11 Field, Double-downs on pledge to remove homeless encampments in 30 days upon assuming office! By...

Column: Response to Nick Antonicello’s Recent Yo! Venice Pieces About the City’s Failure to Take Any Steps to Effectively Deal With Homelessness

May 3, 2022

May 3, 2022

By Clark Brown, Member Venice Neighborhood Council Nick Antonicello’s recent columns in Yo! Venice regarding the City’s failure to take...

Column: An Open Letter To LA County Sheriff Alex Villanueva – Help Us Cleanup Centennial Park Now!

April 29, 2022

April 29, 2022

Dear Sheriff Villanueva: The residents of Venice need your help once again. This time, we need your help to take...

Column: No Need for a ‘Tsar,’ the Need Is Results in Getting the Homeless off the Streets of LA & Venice Now!

April 21, 2022

April 21, 2022

By Nick Antonicello Venice resident Michael Rapkin’s awkward and highly controversial premise that a single position or individual can somehow...

Column: Rick Caruso On Taxes, Just Like Trump?

April 21, 2022

April 21, 2022

By Nick Antonicello In a press conference held Monday in Marina Del Rey, L.A. City Attorney & Mayoral Candidate Mike...

Column: “We Need A Working-Class Minority Voice That Is Centered For The Rest Are Just More Of The Same.”

April 18, 2022

April 18, 2022

Venice HS Teacher, Union Rep and All-American Track Star makes the case for real change in CD-11 race to succeed...

Independent Expenditures Committee Raises $550,000 in Support of Council Candidates Soto, Price and Good, KDL for Mayor, Opposing O’Farrell for Council!

April 14, 2022

April 14, 2022

Column by Nick Antonicello According to the Los Angeles Ethics Commission, a political independent expenditures committee has raised $550,000 to...