December 12, 2024 #1 Local News, Forum, Information and Event Source for Venice Beach, California.

City Hall gridlock stymies relief for residents in Venice, Citywide

ABOVE: All of this would be banned from Venice Beach – day and night – under the already adopted parks ordinance (LAMC 63.44).

Columnist Mark Ryavec.
Columnist Mark Ryavec.

By Mark Ryavec

An effort by the majority of the Los Angeles City Council to take a bold, new direction to addressing troublesome encampments throughout the City remains gridlocked due to the objections of Mayor Eric Garcetti and a small band of councilmembers on the Homelessness Committee, including Councilman Gil Cedillo and our own councilman Mike Bonin.

A new strict ban on storage of any private property in city parks and strict limits on storage of private property on sidewalks and parkways went into effect July 18 but both the LAPD and Bureau of Sanitation representatives tell me that they have been given no instructions about enforcing them.

In the meantime, the Council’s Homelessness and Poverty Committee took up proposed amendments by Councilmen Cedillo and Bonin, the latter’s proposals incorporating the Mayor’s concerns. Taken together, the amendments will so weaken the sidewalks ordinance as to render it unenforceable.

The most troublesome aspects of the Garcetti/Cedillo/Bonin amendments that were voted out of committee would have removed a misdemeanor charge for violating the sidewalks ordinance, added a near-impossible requirement for city employees to separate personal documents, medications and other personal items from everything else found on a sidewalk, and the requirement that the City offer storage facilities within two miles for items seized before the City could clear a sidewalk.

The cost of this latter proposal is astronomical. As we have pointed out, it would be far better to spend that money on aggressive non-profits like the LAPD Homeless Task Force or the Teen Project to house the homeless, place them in rehab or provide transportation back home to safe, welcoming family members. (Venice Stakeholders Association recently reimbursed the Teen Project for bus tickets to send two young fellows home, one to Chattanooga, Tennessee and the other to Orlando, Florida.)

The new ordinance banning storage of anything in any park (LAMC 63.44) is an innocent victim in all of this. Enforcement is being held up because changes in the sidewalks ordinance might suggest a few minor changes in the parks ordinance to maintain consistency in the municipal code.

VSA have lobbied for the Mayor to let the parks ordinance go into effect immediately. In addition to stopping the overnight storage of anything in a park, which would in our estimation depress the number of people who are, in effect, living along the Boardwalk while storing their stuff in the park, the ordinance also would prohibit taking anything into the park during the day that would not fit into a 50 gallon trash bin (with the exception of beach umbrellas).
So, tents, mattresses, furniture, bike frames, bike carts, shopping carts, etc., would be banned day or night from the Venice Beach Recreation Area and could be removed by either Rec. and Parks or Bureau of Sanitation staff. This is similar to the practices that Santa Monica follows to keep their park areas along the beach clean and inviting.

The new, stricter sidewalks ordinance (LAMC 56.11) was championed by San Pedro Councilman Joe Buscaino. He was an LAPD officer for many years, serving as a Senior Lead Officer in San Pedro right before being elected. Councilman Buscaino has plenty of practical experience with enforcing the several ordinances that apply to parks and sidewalks and made a point of consulting with frontline LAPD officers and Bureau of Sanitation staff in drafting the new ordinance. Unfortunately, one cannot say that Garcetti, Bonin or Cedillo took the same care to talk with those who are charged with implementing the ordinances, instead relying on shibboleths like “don’t criminalize the poor” and “exempt personal documents and medications” to guide them.

As I have written before, societies need laws to prevent noxious behavior by one group from impinging on the quality of life of another. The occupation of sidewalks as camping grounds right next to residences is one behavior that should be prohibited, whether it is by the truly poor, or voluntarily poor young “travelers,” or those who could work but choose a hippie, druggie lifestyle along Venice Beach because for the moment it is allowed.

On the latter concern – personal documents and medications – Garcetti, Cedillo and Bonin have failed to realize that the Lavan Decision requires that most items seized from the sidewalks be stored for 90 days for later retrieval by the owner, so there is no need to have city staff separate them out so they won’t end up in a landfill. The new version of 56.11 also allows the owner to simply remove the items during the 24 hour notice period and they won’t be seized.

(Why anyone would choose to leave documents and medications unattended on a sidewalk is beyond my imagination. When I backpacked around the world many years ago I never left my passport, cash, credit cards, glasses or prescribed medications unattended. I kept them in a small daypack that went everywhere with me.  But if anyone does this, these items will be stored for later pickup, not disposed of.)

Apparently there have been extensive discussions between several of the council offices, the Mayor’s Office, the City Attorney’s Office, the LAPD, and the Bureau of Sanitation and its Watershed Protection Unit towards finding a middle ground between the Mayor’s and the Homelessness Committee’s amendments, on one hand, and the stricter, original language of the ordinance, on the other hand, which is favored by a majority of the Council. It’s all a work in progress.

In the meantime, VSA urge the Mayor to let both ordinances to go into effect as written, which could take a couple months to be fully operational anyway.

On the other side of the homeless equation – provision of more services and housing – Los Angeles Times writer David Zahniser recently confirmed my earlier assessment that little of the $100 million pledged by the Mayor and several members of the City Council has been identified (other than some already expected grant funds). With the City still facing a structural budget deficit each year and several recent multi-million dollar legal settlements, including $1.4 billion over 30 years for sidewalk repairs, the Mayor’s pledge is simply wishful thinking.

Mark Ryavec is president of the non-profit Venice Stakeholders Association. He formerly served as a Legislative Analyst for the LA City Council and as Chief Deputy Assessor for LA County.

Related Posts

10 Reasons Why Players Prefer to Use Crypto When iGaming in California

September 1, 2024

September 1, 2024

As online gaming continues to evolve, players are increasingly turning to cryptocurrencies as their payment method of choice. In California,...

Is California Going to Legalize Gambling in 2024/2025?

June 5, 2024

June 5, 2024

The issue of gambling legalization in California has been a topic of debate for many years. As the largest state...

Los Angeles Experience Gifts for People Who Don’t Want More Clutter

May 15, 2024

May 15, 2024

Just like you, most gift recipients in Los Angeles don’t want more stuff. The Los Angeles experience gifts on this...

California: Pioneering the Future of Online and Digital Payments

January 11, 2024

January 11, 2024

In the fast-paced digital economy of the 21st century, California has emerged as a powerhouse in the realm of online...

A Guide to the Current Gambling Situation in Canada

January 1, 2024

January 1, 2024

For centuries, gambling has woven itself into the fabric of human culture; in recent years–marking an era where evolution pervades...

Smart Strategies to Save Money in Your Entertainment Budget

December 30, 2023

December 30, 2023

Many individuals and families in today’s fast-paced world share a common goal: finding ways to save money. The entertainment budget...

California’s top sports teams.

December 1, 2023

December 1, 2023

California is known worldwide for a multitude of exciting things. They’re known for their incredible beaches, glorious sunshine, and fabulous...

Your Lucky Numbers: Six Tips Towards Lottery Success

November 30, 2023

November 30, 2023

Have you ever wondered how people win money from the lottery? They may not always hit the jackpot, but they...

Five different ways to unwind.

October 1, 2023

October 1, 2023

Modern life is always busy and it can feel like your to-do list is never ending. When you’re not working,...

Over Half of Short-Term Rentals Advertised in LA Don’t Comply With City’s Home Sharing Ordinance

April 4, 2023

April 4, 2023

Better Neighbors LA report highlights the inadequacies of enforcement measures for short-term rentals in Los Angeles, calling for increased regulation...

Venice Beach Attempted Murder Suspect Arrested in West Virginia

December 22, 2022

December 22, 2022 1

Brandon Manyo Dixon arrest in West Virginia By Sam Catanzaro A man has been arrested for the attempted murder of...

The Current Gambling Situation in California

December 1, 2022

December 1, 2022

Here’s what to know about everything from online casinos to betting in the state. In the U.S., gambling is a...

Cancer Cartel Provides Financial Help To Cancer Patients

November 16, 2022

November 16, 2022 2

Cancer Cartel is helping cancer patients focus on their treatment, not the financial stress of living with a diagnosis. Learn...

100 Miles of Bus-Only Lanes Within Five Years on City Council Plans

October 17, 2022

October 17, 2022

L.A’s public transportation network is known for being slow due to traffic congestion. A new motion by L.A. City Council...