August 18, 2019 #1 Local News, Forum, Information and Event Source for Venice Beach, California.

FAA Meets with City of SM in Dispute

By Mark Smith

The last time the City of Santa Monica appeared in the D.C. Circuit Court was back in October of 2010 when the City was the Petitioner and the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) was the Respondent. On Monday, May 14, in the same courtroom, the City of Santa Monica and the FAA were odd bedfellows, sharing the same table as Respondents, defending their 2017 Consent Decree agreement.

Hanging on the walls of the D.C. Circuit courtroom are more than 30 oil painting portraits of D.C. Circuit judges (many of whom have become Supreme Court Justices) as a reminder, the only higher court than this District Court, is the Supreme Court.

Richard Simon was first, speaking for the Petitioners. He did not get far before the Judges asked why is this case was in their courtroom if another Judge had signed a Consent Decree. Simon pointed out, “this is the court, in our view, that handles most administrative law issues, this is a national issue, a national case, here we are.”

In February of 2017, aviation interest groups and aviation business filed a Petition to Review a FAA order, asking the D.C. Circuit Court to invalidate the Settlement Agreement between the FAA and the City of Santa Monica. The agreement, signed by City Manager Rick Cole and FAA Chief Counsel Reginald F. Govan, gave the City of Santa Monica permission to shorten the 4990 foot runway to 3500 feet and close the airport in December, 2028.

The Settlement Agreement was signed the last weekend of January 27th 2017 and then ratified a few days later as a Consent Decree by US District Court for Central California. An attorney familiar with Federal law said, “it is an unusual agreement, an unusual document, executed in an unusual manner.”

Back in 2010, the City of Santa Monica and several neighborhood groups were asking the court to uphold a City ordinance banning C and D category aircraft. This was an attempt to ban jets at the Santa Monica Airport. The City financed this unsuccessful legal action against the FAA with over $6 Million of funds from the airport fund. The current Settlement Agreement, succeeded where the C and D legal action failed. In December 2017, the City spent $3.2 million to shorten the runway. According to the Santa Monica Airport website, the new 3500 foot runway has reduced jet traffic by over 80 percent.

The Justice Department Attorney representing the FAA, Tyce R. Walters, pointed out, “this agreement (between the FAA and the City of Santa Monica) would have no force were it not entered as a Consent Decree.”

The practical question for the D.C. Circuit Court; does the FAA have the authority to relieve the City of Santa Monica from grant assurances and deed obligations to operate the airport in perpetuity?  Additional subjects address statutory requirements, including no public comment and no FAA documentation of its decision-making process.

When the Judges asked why this case should not go back to California, Deanne E. Maynard, the attorney for the City of Santa Monica from the law firm Morrison & Foerster, said, “just the notion that they would have to take an order from this court to the court in California shows what an odd procedure this is.”

The D.C. Circuit Court is expected to rule later this year.

Related Posts

LAPD Apprehends Bio-Hazard Waste Dumping RV Dwellers

October 12, 2010

October 12, 2010

Earlier today the LAPD Pacific Division apprehended the bio-hazard waste dumping RV dwellers that had remained at large with a...

NPR: At Venice Beach, Rich, Poor And Middle Class Coexist

July 13, 2014

July 13, 2014

A new radio piece from NPR’s “All Things Considered” released today discusses the benefits to economic mobility of living in...

Water Main Breaks (Again) on Carrol Canal

July 15, 2014

July 15, 2014

Nick Antonicello just sent in this photo from the scene where a water main broke last night on the 200...

Lightning Strike Causes Injuries, 1 Death

July 27, 2014

July 27, 2014

We were exiting the 10 Freeway at Lincoln when we heard a MASSIVE thunderclap, which apparently caused a number of...

Mirror Media Group acquires Yo! Venice!

July 30, 2014

July 30, 2014

Mirror Media Group, the Westside’s largest local media company, has acquired yovenicenew.wpengine.com. Yo! Venice! website founder Bret Haller, 45, died...

LAPD Pacific Division warns of increase in burglaries during summer

August 1, 2014

August 1, 2014

The Los Angeles Police Department Pacific Division has issued a number of Summertime Burglary Prevention Tips, saying “burglars don’t stop...

Former Maker Studios Co-Founder Raises $25 Million for Venice’s Zealot

August 4, 2014

August 4, 2014

The ousted former CEO and co-founder of Maker Studios has reportedly raised $25 million to launch Zealot Networks, a digital...

Venice Neighborhood Council Meetings This Week

August 4, 2014

August 4, 2014

This first full week of August features four meetings for the Venice Neighborhood Council (VNC). VNC’s Housing Committee meets Aug....

VNC Planning Committee to discuss Housing Audit Bill

August 5, 2014

August 5, 2014

The Venice Neighborhood Council (VNC) could be deciding Tuesday, Aug. 5 whether to support a bill in Sacramento to audit...

New app touted as AMBER alert for cardiac arrest victims

August 6, 2014

August 6, 2014

A mobile app that allows users to render immediate aid to cardiac arrest victims in their vicinity will be launched...

Los Angeles Arts Sustainability Tour comes to Venice

August 6, 2014

August 6, 2014

The Los Angeles Arts Sustainability Tour (LAAST), an informative and fun neighborhood event, will take place on Sat., Aug. 9...

County Looks at Marketing Firm for Obesity Program

August 6, 2014

August 6, 2014

A local marketing firm just a few blocks east of Venice could be helping County officials to do a media...

Los Angeles to Combat Illegal Vending on Venice Boardwalk

August 7, 2014

August 7, 2014

Los Angeles will crackdown on what it describes as “illegal vending” on the Venice Beach Boardwalk, as the City Council unanimously...

Ralph Terrazas named Los Angeles Fire Department Chief

August 8, 2014

August 8, 2014

Los Angeles Fire Department Assistant Chief Ralph Terrazas won the unanimous support of the City Council today to become the...

Venice councilman seconds motion for “Czar” to coordinate homeless services

August 9, 2014

August 9, 2014

A Los Angeles city councilman said on Friday a “czar” should be brought in to coordinate services for the homeless...