September 27, 2020 #1 Local News, Forum, Information and Event Source for Venice Beach, California.

L.A. Council Committee Backs Removal of Criminal Penalties from Law Targeting Encampments

A Los Angeles City Council committee on Wednesday backed the removal of criminal penalties and fines from a recently adopted law that created a process for impounding property, including belongings of the homeless, left in public areas.

The City Council earlier this summer approved the law that set rules for removing items left on sidewalks, streets and other areas in public rights-of- way.

The new law, which shortened the noticing period for removing items from 72 hours to 24 hours, replaced an earlier law that city officials said was too broad and rendered anything left on the ground vulnerable to seizure.

But some advocates for the homeless opposed both versions of the law and criticized the new one as needlessly criminalizing homeless people who have no choice but to keep their belongings with them while they are living on the street.

The City Council’s Homelessness and Poverty Committee appeared to address these criticisms today, voting 3-2 to support an amendment removing all criminal penalties and fines from the law. The panel instructed the City Attorney’s Office to prepare a draft of the amendment and report back to the committee.

The committee’s co-chair, Councilman Marqueece Harris-Dawson, questioned why it was necessary to issue misdemeanor citations when the law already allows city officials to confiscate items.

“We have the legal authority to confiscate people’s belongings without this business of a misdemeanor?” he asked. “I just want to make sure I’m clear on that.”

A deputy city attorney responded that assistance from law enforcement is often needed due to “potential resistance,” but nothing in the law requires that a citation is needed to remove the belongings.

Harris-Dawson also said there are laws that allow law enforcement to make arrests, noting that “15 years ago, I was arrested for sitting down on a lawn trying to save affirmative action, before any of this.”

“We didn’t need to create a new way for people to go to jail — we have a lot of those,” he said.

City sanitation workers have raised concerns that removing criminal penalties from the ordinance would make it harder to enforce the law, according to city staff report.

Other committee members were unwilling to part with the penalties, with Councilman Mike Bonin saying he prefers a “graduated penalty system” to deter repeat offenders.

The panel also backed an amendment that addressed another criticism law – – which is that the city can take items from the homeless even if the items are attended and there is no other place to put them. The amendment would distinguish items that are attended by their owner and would prohibit the removal of attended items if there is no voluntary storage facility within a two-mile radius.

Nicholas Campbell, an analyst from the City Administrative Office told the panel that the amendment could stall the law’s enforcement for an “unknown amount of time” in some parts of the city.

“It could be months and in some case years in some parts of the city before you could enforce (the law) because of the challenges with locating storage,” Campbell said. “There are some places where it may be extremely challenging and there are some places where it may be easier.”

Bonin said that fact “underscores the problem” presented by the ordinance, which is that the city could “wind up for a couple of years criminalizing and seizing property because we’re not offering an alternative.”

“It’s going to be hard,” he said. “It’s going to be a huge pain in the butt to cite anything in my district,” which includes the Venice Beach area.

A proposal by Councilman Gil Cedillo to suspend the law while it is being revised failed on a vote of 4-1, with some members saying they still need the ordinance to address the accumulation of trash in the city.

“Suspending this ordinance entirely and not being able to remove unattended belongings means, effectively, we will not be able to pick up trash and debris in some of our streets,” Bonin said.

Bonin also said that suspension is “moot,” because the law is “only enforceable with voluntary storage.”

Cedillo argued that the law should be developed at the “front end.” The committee is working to make the law “sharper and clearer, more focused, removing the criminalization … but we’re not there yet,” he said.

Related Posts

Abbot Kinney’s 1905 Home For Sale

June 17, 2019

June 17, 2019

By Keldine Hull Tobacco magnate and multi-millionaire Abbot Kinney furrowed the first canals in the untapped areas to the west...

Boardwalk One Step Closer to Chain Ban

April 17, 2019

April 17, 2019 1

Los Angeles City Council calls for a feasibility study for retail chain ban on Ocean Front Walk. By Sam Catanzaro...

Venice Beach Among Most Instagrammable Locations in the U.S.

February 19, 2019

February 19, 2019

By Sam Catanzaro A recent study has pegged Venice Beach as the ninth-most Instagrammable location in the United States. According...

Edify TV Live: The Wee Chippy

February 1, 2019

February 1, 2019

By Edify TV Edify TV Live visits The Wee Chippy on Ocean Front Walk in Venice to learn about their...

City Attorney Settles with Venice Beach Suites

January 29, 2019

January 29, 2019

By Staff Writer City Attorney Mike Feuer today announced that his office has secured a settlement with Venice Beach Suites,...

Letter to the Editor: Ocean Front Walk Safety

January 15, 2019

January 15, 2019

By Stephen Meadows As a retired engineering professor and patented inventor, I have lived in Venice beach since 1987. I served...

Bonin Proposes Boardwalk Ban on Retail Chains 

December 3, 2018

December 3, 2018

Venice Councilmember submits legislation to preserve unique character of Ocean Front Walk. By Sam Catanzaro  Last week, the Santa Monica City...

Street Musician Stabbed on Venice Beach Boardwalk

November 27, 2018

November 27, 2018 1

Male suspect taken into custody.  By Sam Catanzaro  The Los Angeles Police Department (LAPD) have taken a man into custody...

Venice Beach Named World’s Most Valuable Beach

July 19, 2018

July 19, 2018

$3.1 billion evaluation despite homelessness crisis. By Sam Catanzaro Fifteen years ago, Venice Beach was known around the world for...

Letter to the Editor: Venice Pier Fire

July 18, 2018

July 18, 2018

The electrical fire at the Venice Pier is a symptom of a far worse scenario that exists at the beach...

CBD by the Sea

July 10, 2018

July 10, 2018

Venice Circle has something for everybody. By Sam Catanzaro Summer fun in Venice can mean sore muscles and joints from...

Bike Theft on the Rise in Venice

June 15, 2018

June 15, 2018 1

Registering your bike online may help you reclaim your ride. By Sam Catanzaro The fear of returning to find their...

Ocean Front Walk Machete Stabbing

May 24, 2018

May 24, 2018

Three hospitalized in a fight involving a machete Monday night.    By Sam Catanzaro A stabbing occurred Monday night on Ocean...

Venice Crime Spike

April 16, 2018

April 16, 2018 2

Two shootings and serial burglar cause concern. By Sam Catanzaro After two shootings occurred on Windward Ave in a span...